I went into 'Captain America: The First Avenger' with somewhat mixed expectations. My inner fanboy wanted it to be great, but the summer had thus far disappointed, with a lackluster Green Lantern, and a thoroughly average Thor. As a geek, I was worried and anxious. Advanced reviews were coming in positive and Captain America looked positioned to be the comic book film to beat this year. And it is. Although the film is far from perfect, and I am still waiting for Marvel Studios to WOW us, as D.C. and Warner Brothers have in the past, 'Captain America: The First Avenger', is fun, well acted and well paced summer action fare.
As the film opens, we are introduced to the film's villain, one Johann Schmidt a.k.a. the Red Skull played by Hugo Weaving. Schmidt is a Nazi officer who is obsessed with becoming a god, and has his own plans for the Nazi party using his top secret and powerful 'Hydra' organization. I've read that Weaving decided to do an immitation of Werner Herzog for his accent in the film, but if you ask me he's channeling Willem Defoe.
Now we meet Steve Rogers, a man of physical weakness, but undeniable moral strength. We first see Rogers being rejected by the armed services, and getting bullied by just about everyone he comes into contact with. The effects team did a remarkable job of 'Benjamin Button-ing' Chris Evans down to a size that would put Christian Bale's 'Machinist' role to shame. We find that Steve will not be allowed entry into the army due to his medical history. Rogers wants nothing more than to fight for his country and is proud but saddened when 'Bucky' Barnes (Sebastian Stan) who is Rogers oldest friend, is successfully enlisted and shipped off, leaving Rogers to try enlisting in another city.
Enter Stanley "I can make a bad movie watchable" Tucci as the somewhat weather worn Dr. Abraham Erskine. Erskine overhears Rogers and recognizes the strength within him, so he gives Rogers the chance to join the army. Rogers is put into a special training program under the auspices of Colonel Chester Phillips played by Tommy Lee Jones, and Peggy Carter played by the lovely Haley Atwell. Jones here is his usual charming string of sarcasm and quick wit bringing much humor to the film, but this is really where we get to see Steve Rogers as the unwavering good guy that we know him to be. Where despite his physical stature, he proves that he is the right man for a top secret project.
Rogers is put through a sort of Frankenstein experiment being run by Erskine and Howard Stark (Dominic Cooper) who is the Father of Tony Stark from the Iron Man franchise, and played with a very sly eccentricity by Cooper. The end result of this is Rogers being turned into a tall, fast, super strong, Nazi killing machine.
Captain America suffers from what all Marvel films thus far have suffered (with the possible exception of Spider Man 2), and that is an extremely strong first act followed by a much weaker second act. Captain America's first act is a really solid character piece. There is a distinct lack of development for Steve Rogers, in that he is a solid moral compass for the viewer. He is not meant to change. The great development in this films first half, is the introduction of situations to allow Rogers to truly embrace who he is. The ultimate American. There are great moments of Rogers performing at the U.S.O. events selling war bonds that show us his frustration at not being in the fight, while also paying us geek homage to the origins of his classic costume. Chris Evans has intrigued me for a while. Having seen him mostly in comedies, I think he has great comedic chops. But ever since Danny Boyle's 'Sunshine', I have wanted to see more of him in serious work and to show his range. In Captain America, he does that. And he does it quite well. I think Evans will surprise a lot of people with his earnest, and believable performance.
When Cap finally does embrace himself and join the fight is where this movie kind of starts on the downslide for me. Rogers finds that his friend Bucky has ben captured along with most of the rest of his division, and decides to mount a rescue without permission from his superiors. We are introduced to the "Howlin' commandos" led by 'Dum-Dum' Dugan (an almost unrecognizable Neal McDonough) who are greatfull for the rescue, and ready to fight back.
Next we are shown a series of missions run by Captain America and the howlin' commandos in the form of a series of montages.The action sequences are over the top and wholly from the comic book mindset, complete with giant tanks and laser guns. It looks like a comic book, but at times it seems too campy and out of place with the first half of the film. By the time the climax rolls around, I felt like I was watching a different movie than I was an hour ago.
There is also a love interest hinted at but not developed between Rogers and Atwell's Peggy Carter. Their romantic connection seems a bit forced, and is I think a set up to further develop Rogers character in 'The Avengers', but most of her screentime seeems slightly wasted. I would have also liked to see more of Toby Jones as the Red Skull's henchman Dr. Zola. There is a wonderfully funy scene with Tommy Lee Jones' Colonel Phillips interrogating Toby Jones' Dr. Zola who just oozes creepy evil German.
The ending of the film is in the Marvel tradition of setting up for the next film, in this case 'The Avengers'. This also feels a bit out of place. Although it does set up some interesting story points for Steve Rogers in the next film.
All in al I believe that Captain America is the best of the summer batch of super heroes. Is it great? No. Is it better than Thor? I think so. Is it better than Iron Man? I'm not sure yet. It IS a very fun, entertaining, and well acted summer popcorn super hero fix!
***